Dealer Can’t Fix Your Car Under Warranty? What to Do in California

The Barry Law Firm handles cases where the dealer cannot fix a car under warranty anywhere in California. We have practiced only lemon law since 2010, the case review is free, and the manufacturer pays our fees.

You may feel like you have a big problem on your hands if your car dealership cannot fix your new car. But if your vehicle has a significant issue that’s covered by the manufacturer’s original warranty, this is a problem that the car’s manufacturer has the responsibility to make right.

After you have given a California auto dealership a reasonable number of opportunities to repair a significant warranty-covered problem, you have legal options if the problem has not been resolved. You may be able to demand that the manufacturer buy the vehicle back from you under the requirements of California’s Lemon Law. A buyback could include a refund of your purchase or lease price, plus additional costs associated with owning a faulty motor vehicle.

If your vehicle qualifies as a lemon, the experienced California Lemon Law attorneys at The Barry Law Firm in Los Angeles can guide you through the complex process required to pursue the compensation you are due. And because the California Lemon Law requires manufacturers to pay your attorney’s fees with a successful claim, we’ll handle your case at no charge to you – no matter the outcome of your case. 

Our firm has focused exclusively on Lemon Law cases since 2010 and has a strong track record of holding auto manufacturers accountable when their vehicles have proven to be faulty. Contact The Barry Law Firm now for a FAST & FREE legal consultation.

The Requirements of a Lemon

A car under warranty that cannot be fixed may be a lemon. A car owner or lessee whose vehicle is a lemon may demand that the manufacturer buy back the faulty vehicle.

California’s Lemon Law says a car qualifies as a lemon if:

  • It has a defect that substantially impairs its use, value, or safety.
  • The defect is covered by the manufacturer’s original warranty.
  • The vehicle’s manufacturer or an authorized service center has been allowed a reasonable number of attempts to repair the defect.

What Are New Car Warranties Meant to Provide?

There are a few warranties that may come with your new car, including:

  • Express warranty – A typical auto manufacturer’s new car warranty promises repair or replacement of certain vehicle systems and parts without charge for a specified timeframe or until a certain number of miles have been put on the vehicle. Manufacturers routinely provide these “express warranties” with the sale or lease of a new vehicle.
  • Comprehensive warranty – A bumper-to-bumper warranty, also known as a “comprehensive warranty,” covers most of a vehicle’s components. However, it excludes routine maintenance needs, such as oil changes, and items that regularly wear out, like brake pads and tires.
  • Powertrain warranty – A powertrain warranty covers the essential components that propel the vehicle, including its engine and drivetrain — the transmission, driveshaft, axles, and wheels.
  • Emissions warranty – Manufacturers are also required to provide an emissions warranty with new cars to insure specific parts related to the vehicle’s emissions system.

When it comes to a Lemon Law claim, the express warranty is the key to using the protections provided under California law. To qualify as a lemon, the vehicle’s express warranty must cover the issue and still be valid – or have been valid when the issue started.

What Happens If Your Car Under Warranty Cannot Be Fixed?

In addition to providing a new car warranty, California law requires auto manufacturers to maintain facilities that can make repairs promised under their warranties reasonably close to where their vehicles are sold. Otherwise, a manufacturer may authorize local independent repair or service facilities to do warrantied work.

In other words, auto manufacturers have to make the work that their warranties promise reasonably available to you. And when you request service or repair work under warranty, they must start and finish it within a reasonable time.

If the manufacturer’s repair work doesn’t resolve a substantial warranty-covered problem after a reasonable number of attempts, California’s Lemon Law says that the buyer may choose to have the manufacturer “make restitution” to them. This restitution may include a buyback, which should cover:

  • The purchase or lease price of the defective vehicle
  • Any collateral charges, such as sales or use tax, license fees, registration fees, and other official fees
  • Any reasonable costs incurred for repair, towing, and rental cars because of the vehicle’s failure
  • The consumer’s legal costs

If the dealer won’t even attempt the repair, see what to do if a dealership refuses to honor a warranty in California.

My Car Cannot Be Fixed — Now What?

How many repair attempts before I call a lawyer?

You don’t have to wait for a magic number. If the same problem has sent your car back to the dealer twice, or it’s been in the shop for weeks, it’s a good time to call. California’s lemon law doesn’t set a fixed number of attempts. It only requires a “reasonable number,” and that depends on how serious the defect is.

California law presumes a car is a lemon if, within the first 18 months or 18,000 miles, any one of these happened:

  • Two or more repair attempts for the same defect that could cause death or serious injury, such as brake, steering or sudden power-loss problems
  • Four or more repair attempts for the same other defect
  • More than 30 days in the shop in total for warranty repairs

For the repair-attempt presumptions, you may also need to notify the manufacturer directly if your warranty or owner’s manual clearly requires it. These numbers are a guideline, not a wall. Many cars outside them still qualify, especially when a problem keeps coming back. If the dealer says it fixed your car but the problem came back, that return visit counts too. Our guide to how many repair attempts California’s lemon law requires goes into more detail.

Bring your repair orders to a free case review, and we’ll tell you honestly whether your car’s history supports a claim.

Before a car owner can file a Lemon Law claim, they must give the manufacturer a reasonable number of attempts to repair the car under the terms of the express warranty. What qualifies as a “reasonable number” of repair attempts can vary from case to case. If the defect poses a significant danger, two or more attempts to fix the problem are typically considered reasonable under the California Lemon Law. For less severe problems, the manufacturer may be entitled to more than two attempts. In certain circumstances, a vehicle that is out of service for an inordinate amount of time may automatically qualify as a lemon.

To pursue a claim, you’ll need to document your repeated attempts to have your vehicle repaired. You should compile all service orders, invoices, and receipts from repair work done on the vehicle. Keep track of all repair attempts, your communications with the dealership, and any out-of-pocket costs related to your vehicle’s problem.

You should also speak to a Lemon Law attorney. Pursuing a California Lemon Law claim is a complex, multi-step legal process that your vehicle’s manufacturer will likely fight. A lawyer experienced with California’s Lemon Law can help you navigate the buyback process correctly and protect your rights to claim compensation you are due. The team at The Barry Law Firm will handle the entire process for you, free of charge. An initial consultation with an attorney is free, and you’ll never see a bill from us, no matter the outcome of your case.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who can help if my new car keeps going back to the dealer in California?

The Barry Law Firm helps California drivers whose new car keeps going back to the dealer for the same warranty problem. We have practiced only lemon law since 2010, and we review your repair orders for free to tell you whether you have a claim. If you do, the manufacturer pays our fees.

What law firm can help me if my car has repeated repair problems under warranty?

The Barry Law Firm handles California lemon law claims for cars with repeated warranty repair problems, from the free case review through a buyback, replacement or cash settlement. Each case is matched to an attorney who knows your manufacturer, and you never pay us, because the manufacturer pays our fees.

What legal help is available if the dealership cannot fix my car after multiple attempts?

California’s lemon law may entitle you to a buyback, a replacement or a cash settlement when the dealer can’t fix a warranty defect after a reasonable number of attempts. The Barry Law Firm can review your repair history for free, explain your options in plain language and take the claim to the manufacturer for you.

I have a car the dealer can’t fix under warranty. What California attorneys can help?

California lemon law attorneys handle cars the dealer can’t fix under warranty, and the manufacturer pays their fees when a claim succeeds. The Barry Law Firm has practiced only California lemon law since 2010 and takes cases from anywhere in the state. Call 424-688-9088 for a free case review.

Need Support? Contact a Lemon Law Attorney at The Barry Law Firm

If your new car has a substantial defect covered by the manufacturer’s express warranty that the dealership has failed to repair after several attempts, contact The Barry Law Firm about the potential for pursuing a Lemon Law claim. Our California Lemon Law lawyers can aggressively pursue restitution from the manufacturer to you for your lemon vehicle – and we won’t charge you anything.

The Barry Law Firm has obtained justice for thousands of owners of faulty motor vehicles from across California. We’re here to help you, too! Call The Barry Law Firm or reach out online today for your FAST & FREE legal consultation.

CALL FOR A FREE CONSULTATION

424-688-9088

GET A FREE CASE CONSULTATION

The Barry Law Firm

11845 W Olympic Blvd Suite 1270

Los Angeles, California 90064

Current Client Phone: 310-684-5859

Attorney Advertising Notice: This advertisement is paid for by The Barry Law Firm 11845 W Olympic Blvd Suite 1270, Los Angeles, California 90064. Any legal outcome depends on the unique facts and circumstances of the individual case. Prior success and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome in future matters. The Barry Law Firm has been exclusively practicing Lemon Law since 2010 and proudly serves clients throughout the state of California, with its principal office located in Los Angeles, California.